27th May 2025
A quick guide into the allocation of recovery proceeds in subrogation
by Sora Jeon* and Cesar Peniche±
Embedded deep within the heart of insurance law, the doctrine of subrogation echoes various legal principles, such as the principle of indemnity and the avoidance of double recovery.
In essence, what the doctrine of subrogation dictates is that, in principle, once the insurer has indemnified the assured, the insurer becomes entitled to take over all of the rights of the assured to recover the sums he paid under the contract of insurance against the person responsible for the loss.
In order for subrogation to take effect, various elements must be present. Among others, these are that:
- A contract of insurance is required – i.e. a contract providing indemnity to the assured in the event that the risk covered is materialised;
- The insurer must have indemnified the assured for the losses covered under the policy (and not solely for the claim which the insurer wishes to be subrogated into); and
- There must be no waiver of subrogation.
The subrogated insurer will either take over the rights of the assured to recover from the third party wrongdoer, or the insurer will become entitled to the proceeds that the assured received from such third party. Nevertheless, this latter form of subrogation is subject to the following important qualifications:
- The insurer will recover only to the extent of the indemnity he paid to the assured; and
- The third-party recovery must diminish or extinguish the assured’s loss.
This is in line with the nature of the insurance contract, which is that the assured will be indemnified for his loss but no more and that the insurer will be entitled to recover what they paid, resulting in the avoidance of any double recovery by the assured. In fact, the insurer will have an equitable lien over these proceeds, i.e. a chose in possession against the assured[1].
On its face, the doctrine of subrogation appears to be straightforward. However, where the insurer pays and is thereafter entitled to what the assured receives from the wrongdoer, how will the recovery proceeds be allocated as between the insurers and the assured?
In order to determine how these proceeds will be allocated, it will be necessary to differentiate between full and partial insurance. To that effect, let us consider the following scenarios where the assured (“A”) insures his vessel (“V”) with insurer (“I”).
SCENARIO A – Full indemnity to the assured for his actual loss
Assuming that I has indemnified A for the full extent of A’s actual loss, I would then recover from the wrongdoer the amount paid out under that policy. If the policy is a valued policy, the value determined by the parties is conclusive, and the assured cannot argue that they have suffered greater loss than indemnified by the insurer.
If the assured recovers from the third party a sum larger than his actual loss, e.g. due to currency fluctuation[2], any excess in A’s recovery from the third party, i.e. any amount recovered which falls beyond the actual loss suffered by the assured and indemnified by the insurer, will be retained by A. This is only logical, given that any such excess would not diminish the loss, i.e. the assured’s loss would have already been covered by the insurer’s payment and any excess would not refer to the assured’s actual loss.

SCENARIO B – Indemnity to the assured does not exhaust his actual loss
The situation is more complicated when A is not fully indemnified by I for his actual loss.
When the proceeds of A’s recovery are not sufficient to cover both of I’s indemnity and the remainder of A’s actual loss, then a question arises as to who should retain the proceeds of any recovery – i.e. whether that would be the insurer who paid out to the assured, albeit not to the full extent of the assured’s loss, or the assured who has not received a full indemnity for his loss.
In such circumstances, a consideration must be given as to how such an apportionment should be made and which party will take priority. As this will largely depend on the nature of the policy and the uninsured loss, three different alternative scenarios are set out below.

Scenario B1 – Insurer’s priority
If A and I have entered into an insurance policy, wherein the value of V is agreed (i.e. a valued policy) and I has subsequently indemnified A for the full amount stated to be the value of V in the policy, then I will have priority in recovering up to the amount he has paid to A from any proceeds that A receives from the third-party – the policy value is conclusive evidence of the loss suffered by the assured, regardless of the fact that A’s loss may be more than this agreed value. The principle would also be applicable in cases of partial loss under the insurance policy.

Scenario B2 – Pro rata allocation
Let us now assume that the V is under-insured or partially insured. In these circumstances, in the absence of agreement to the contrary, pursuant to s. 81 of the Marine Insurance Act 1906, the assured is considered to be his own insurer for the part of the value not covered by the insurer:
“Where the assured is insured for an amount less than the insurable value or, in the case of a valued policy, for an amount less than the policy valuation, he is deemed to be his own insurer in respect of the uninsured balance.”
In light of the above, it could be said that the V is fully insured, partially by I and partially by A himself. In these circumstances, the default position in relation to the allocation of any proceeds would be to allocate them pro ratabetween the insurers (herein I and A) – the same position would apply in the circumstances where the V would be insured by multiple insurers, i.e. I1, I2, I3 etc.
The above position was illustrated in the Court of Appeal decision of The Commonwealth [1907] P. 216. In this case, a schooner named Welsh Girl collided with the steamship Commonwealth under foggy weather conditions. As a result of the collision, the Welsh Girl sunk. The Welsh Girl was insured for £1,000 – the agreed asset value was £1,350. Following indemnification from their insurers to the amount of £1,000, the owners of the vessel recovered £1,000 from the third party. The Court decided that both the insurer and the assured were entitled to the third-party recovery proceeds and that these proceeds would be allocated between the parties pro rata, i.e. each party would recover to the extent of the loss which it had agreed to bear. Therefore, the assured’s recovery would amount to 350/1,350 of the proceeds (i.e. the fraction of the loss which the assured had personally borne) and the insurer’s recovery would amount to the remaining 1,000/1,350 (i.e. the fraction of the loss which was insured out and indemnified to the assured).

Scenario B3 – Top-down allocation
The position is different when the insurance policy is layered. A policy will be so layered when the cover provider will indemnify for the loss only insofar as another cover provider is not liable to pay. For example, an assured may have undertaken to cover his own losses up to a specified amount (i.e. the assured is self-insured up to this amount). If the loss exceeds this amount, then the insurer will step in and indemnify the assured for the losses over and above the specified amount. Equally, the reverse may be agreed, i.e. that an insurer will indemnify the assured for the losses up to a specified amount, but the assured will cover his own losses (he will be self-insured) for any loss above this amount. In these circumstances, in the absence of agreement to the contrary, the proceeds would be allocated from the top down, i.e. first to the top layer insurer (the insurer who undertook to indemnify the assured only if the bottom layers were not sufficient), then to the next layer insurer and so on.
The top-down approach was established in the aforementioned House of Lords decision in the non-marine case of Lord Napier and Ettrick v RF Kershaw Ltd (“Napier”). In short, this case demonstrates that, when an insurer has agreed to bear a loss but only if a specified level of loss is exceeded (e.g. where there is a deductible to be absorbed by the assured or excess insurance), then this insurer will have priority in recovering from third-party proceeds over the next layer of insurers.
Lord Templeman provided the following useful illustration of how the top-down approach operates:
Under a stop-loss insurance policy, an insurer agrees to provide indemnity to the assured for his losses, so long as these exceed a specified amount but do not exceed a set policy limit. In particular, an assured covers himself for the first uninsured £25,000. The first insurer then becomes liable to indemnify the assured for any loss exceeding £25,000, but up to the amount of £125,000. Any loss over this limit would, again, be covered by the assured himself. In these circumstances, any third-party recovery proceeds would be allocated between the parties on a top-down basis – i.e. the assured would be entitled to recover first from the proceeds in respect of any loss in excess of the £125,000. Thereafter, the insurer would be entitled to any excess of the recovery proceeds in order to recoup for the sums he indemnified to the assured (i.e. for any losses between £25,000 and £125,000). Finally, the assured would, again, be entitled to recover from any remaining recovery proceeds in respect of any loss he had further self-insured (i.e. for any losses under the first £25,000).

For illustration purposes, we set out the following example. Let us assume, as under the above premise, that an assured has undertaken to cover his own losses for the first £25,000, following which the insurer will indemnify him up to the amount of £125,000. Any sum over and above the £125,000 will again be covered by the assured himself. If the recovery from a third-party made by the assured amounted to £80,000 on an actual loss of £150,000, then the allocation of these proceeds would be formulated as follows:
- The first £25,000 would be received by the top-layer insurer, i.e. the insurer who agreed to indemnify only if the middle and the bottom layers of cover did not suffice (in the present circumstances, this would be the assured who was self-insured);
- The next £55,000 would be received by the middle layer insurer, i.e. the insurer who undertook to provide indemnity only insofar as the bottom layer cover did not suffice (in this case, the actual insurer); and
- Finally, the bottom layer insurer, i.e. again the assured who was self-insured for the first £25,000, would not receive any further part of the recovery proceeds, as the sum of the proceeds would have already been exhausted.
According to Arnould [3] (the leading textbook in marine insurance law), the top-down approach can arguably be applied in the circumstances where the bottom layer is the deductible of the policy. This is of sound logic as, by agreeing to first cover part of the loss by way of deductible, the assured becomes his own insurer for part of the loss. Any subsequent indemnity by the insurer will take place only so far as the assured has first borne the first (or bottom) layer of the loss.

Conflicting decisions – where this leaves us
It appears from the above analysis that, although Scenarios B2 and B3 begin from a similar premise, their outcomes are dramatically different. Under Scenario B2, the proceeds are allocated proportionately between I and A (see The Commonwealth), whereas under Scenario B3, the proceeds are allocated on a top-down basis (see Napier).
The question then is whether there is a conflict between these two decisions and, if so, what the default position is.
As a starting point, it should be said that when an “assured is under-insured by reference to the insurable value in an unvalued policy, or partially insured by reference to the agreed value in a valued policy”[4], then the assured is taken to have insured himself for the part not undertaken by the insurer – i.e. the assured undertakes to cover himself for any loss which the insurer has not agreed to bear.
In these circumstances, the default position appears to derive from the decision in The Commonwealth, where it was held that the insurer and the assured will participate proportionately to the allocation of the recovery proceeds. However, the position is further complicated by the decision in Napier.
Although the interaction between these two cases is not clear-cut, it is submitted by the leading book in marine insurance law[5] that the two decisions co-exist. According to Arnould, The Commonwealth was not overruled by Napier. Instead, the application of both of these decisions is as follows:
- In marine policies, where the assured is partially insured or underinsured, the proportionality principle will apply in pursuance of The Commonwealth;
- However, in circumstances where the policy provides a layered cover, then the top-down approach will apply as a result of the House of Lords decision in Napier – despite the fact that the decision in this case did not deal with marine insurance in particular, the wording of the case is arguably wide enough to engulf general principles of insurance law. This has been confirmed by a recent case as explained below.
Recent development: Royal & Sun Alliance v Textair
The above analysis came under scrutiny in the Court of Appeal’s recent decision in the case of Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance Plc v Textainer Group Holdings Ltd [2024] EWCA Civ 547. The case dealt with excess of loss policies incorporating all terms, conditions and warranties of the Marine Insurance Act 1906. Phillips LJ, delivering the lead judgment, evaluated an insurance policy containing a US$5 million retention, a primary policy of US$5 million in excess of retention, and five progressive excess of loss policies, up to US$85 million. The assured, having suffered a loss of US$101.8 million, obtained payment from the policies for a total sum of US$75.1 million (leaving a retention of US$5 million and uninsured losses in the region of US$21 million). The assured then settled his claim with a third party to an amount of US$25.8 million, from which they received payment of US$14.7 million. The insurers then tried to take a bite of this settlement, alleging it should be distributed pro rata.
At the outset, insurers could not rely on a recovery clause within the policy (which would have given insurers preference over the proceeds), since it only applied when recoveries were paid as or towards the amount indemnified. The amount in question (US$14.7 million) did not recoup the uninsured loss, so it did not engage the amounts indemnified. No luck there.
The insurers then tried to argue that Napier and a subsequent High Court decision in Kuwait Airways Corporation v Kuwait Insurance Co S.A.K [2000] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 252 (which reaffirmed the top-down approach in stop loss/excess of loss policies) were distinguishable. Philips LJ sided with the lower Court decision, inasmuch as the alleged differences between the stop loss policy in Napier and the excess of loss policy here did not justify a distinction, nor did they merit parting away from the top-down approach. In fact, both types of policies provided cover against particular layer(s) of loss, which allowed for the application of the top-down approach. Thus, the Court reaffirmed what was upheld at first instance, noting it conformed most closely with the right of the assured of receiving a full indemnity, as well as with the underlying rationale of subrogation (as explained above).
Lastly, the Court of Appeal dealt with a very interesting issue: is the apportionment of recoveries under an excess of loss policy modified by the incorporation of the Marine Insurance Act 1906, particularly section 81? Phillips LJ had recourse to the findings of David Railton KC, sitting as a Deputy Judge of the High Court. In his judgment, he considered that the concept of under-insurance was not relevant “in circumstances where the [insurance] Policies provide excess insurance in respect of particular layers of loss.”[6]. In simple words, “the concept of undervaluation is simply not engaged in relation to layers of insurance”. When insurance covers a defined portion of loss, it matches by definition the value of whatever is being insured, leaving the insurer exposed to a risk only equal to the cover provided. No less, no more. In consequence, risk under a typical excess of loss insurance is ‘undefined and indefinite’, making the principle of average (in s. 81 of the MIA 1906) inapposite to it.
Contractual provisions
In any event, it should be noted that the contractual provisions may set out a different context altogether, departing from the above common law positions. As a result, the policy may include express provisions setting out the effect of the top-down principle, such as:
“Any sums recovered through subrogation proceedings with respect to any loss hereunder shall follow the principle that any interests (including the Assured) that shall have paid an amount over and above any payment hereunder shall first be reimbursed up to the amount paid by them; the Insurers hereon are then to be reimbursed out of any balance then remaining up to the amount paid hereunder; lastly, the interests (including the Assured) of whom this coverage is in excess are entitled to claim the residue, if any.”
This is also the case under the Institute Time Clauses – Hull, clause 12.3 of which provides:
“Excluding any interest comprised therein, recoveries against any claim which is subject to the above deductible shall be credited to the Underwriters in full to the extent of the sum by which the aggregate of the claim unreduced by any recoveries exceeds the above deductible.”
Equally, the opposite is also possible, i.e. a wording setting out the proportionate allocation of recoveries, such as:
“It is noted and agreed that, in respect of any recoveries secured, the Insured and Insurers will apportion funds between themselves in relation to the same proportions in which each has borne the loss”
This is also in line with the International Hull Clauses, clause 49 of which states:
“49.4 In the event of recoveries from third parties in respect of claims which have been paid in whole or in part under this insurance, such recoveries shall be distributed between the Underwriters and the Assured as follows
…
49.4.2 the balance shall be apportioned between the Underwriters and the Assured in the same proportion that the insured losses and uninsured losses bear to the total of the insured and uninsured losses. For the purposes of Clause 49.2 and this Clause 49.4.2, uninsured losses shall mean loss of or damage to the subject-matter insured and any liability or expense which would have been recoverable under this insurance, but for the application of deductible(s) under Clause 15 and the limits of this insurance.”
Conclusion
Approtionment of recovery proceeds can be a complicated issue. It depends both on the particular wording of each policy, as well as the nature and structure of the coverage provided.
Although this article attempts to provide a short guide to the allocation of recoveries, stakeholders are urged to examine each policy on its own merits, always taking into consideration the relevant policy wording.
It is certain that the starting point must always be to check whether the policy has any relevant provisions, either expressly provided or incorporated by reference (such as the standard clauses referred to above). Thereafter, the parties should remain vigilant for any inconsistencies in the policy wording which could affect the contrustion (i.e. interpretation) of the policy wording.
Absent any relevant provisions in the policy, the parties should consider whether their policy provides a layered structure for cover (in which case, it is likely that the top-down approach will apply) or not (in which case, the proportionate approach may apply).
Jeon Macinnes, as experts in the area of insurance are here to assist you in all matters which may arise.
±Foreign Qualified Lawyer at Jeon Macinnes LLP
[1] Lord Napier and Ettrick v RF Kershaw Ltd [1993] A.C. 713
[2] See Yorkshire Insurance Co v Nisbet Shipping Co Ltd [1962] 2 Q.B. 330.
[3] See Arnould: Law of Marine Insurance and Average 21st Ed. paragraph 31-46.
[4] See Arnould: Law of Marine Insurance and Average 21st Ed. paragraph 31-44.
[5] Arnould: Law of Marine Insurance and Average 21st Ed paragraph 31-46.
[6] Royal Sun & Alliance v Textainer [2022] EWHC 1995 (Comm) at [95].